Skip to main content

In the past decades, creative types have spent plenty of time trying to revive our perceptions of old villains from fairy tales or movies to give them sympathetic backstories. If only people knew the external environment in which the villains grew up, this approach goes, we would feel sympathy for them.

In Fyodor Dostoevsky’s Crime and Punishment, however, we find a different approach. Although Dostoevsky does acquaint us with the deprived background of the murderous villain in the story, he does not use it to excuse his behavior. Instead, he reminds us that the murderer’s behavior ultimately stemmed from the villain’s depraved heart. One central feature of his depraved personality, strikingly, is his ingratitude.1

Depraved Ingratitude

The protagonist, Raskolnikov, is not simply ungrateful for things, such as food, clothes, rain, a place to live, etc. He is ungrateful for the highest virtue that is shown by characters throughout the book: agape love (i.e., self-sacrificing love). Instead of seeing these actions as virtuous, he perceives them as foolish behavior forced upon those making sacrifices due to the evil world.

For instance, early in the book, he learns about a young woman named Sonia who has given herself up to prostitution to support her drunk father, destitute mother, and three little siblings. He despises this kind of sacrificial love made necessary by a fallen world. Similarly, he later finds out his sister plans to marry a wealthy man to save the family from poverty even though “Love is not involved.” He thinks toward his sister when hearing about this news in a letter from his mother: “I don’t want your sacrifice” (p. 52).2 He also rejects the genuine sacrifice from his best friend Dmitry, who is willing to give him translation work to ease his poverty.

At the height of his ingratitude, he also rejects the generosity of strangers. A merchant woman with a child gives him twenty kopecks and says, “Take it, my dear man, for Christ’s joy.” (p. 118). He proceeds to take the coin and throw it into the Neva River. Dostoevsky writes of Raskolnikov after that act, “He felt as though he had cut himself off, at that moment, with a scissors as it were, from everything and everyone” (p. 120). That’s what ingratitude does.

Despite Raskolnikov hardness of heart, his friend Dmitry constantly keeps being generous to him with his time, money, and affections. He visits him and takes care of him when he’s sick. Eventually, Raskolnikov responds with this ultimate cry of ingratitude to his friend, who consistently shows him Christ-like love:

Listen, can you see I don’t want your favors? What kind of a game is it, doing favors to people who despise them? To people who loathe favors, I mean? Why did you look me up when I first took sick? How did you know I wouldn’t have been delighted to die? Haven’t I made it clear to you today that you’re torturing me, that you make me sick! You seem to get a kick out of torturing people!… How can I persuade you not to pursue me with your favors? I don’t care if you think I’m ungrateful. I don’t care if you think I’m low, as long as you just leave me alone! You hear? Leave me alone! (170-71)

That is the cry of the deeply depraved ingrate in the face of generous agape love, God’s love. 

Discerning the Motives of the Giver

Astutely, Dostoevsky also shows us that the charitable relationship of the giver to the receiver can take two forms. Raskolnikov despises his sister’s rich fiancé with the accusing question, “Is it true that you told your bride…at the very time you received her consent, how glad you were that she was a beggar…because it’s more profitable saving a wife from beggary—you can lord it over her and remind her she’s in your debt?” (p. 156). In this case, Raskolnikov rightly perceives that the rich fiancé is hoping for servile gratitude from his future wife. Fortunately, his sister realizes this point and ends up marrying Raskolnikov’s friend Dmitry.

Dmitry, as I revealed earlier, is the Christ-like friend who has shown himself to be a generous giver who does not attach manipulative strings to his generosity. Here Dostoevsky teaches us to be discerning concerning the giver of what appears to be charity and who we receive it from. Some give to enslave while others give to free us to be who we are made to be.

Despising Christ-like Agape Love

But Raskolnikov despises generosity not only from the manipulator but also from the Christ-like self-sacrificer, whoever they may be. He despises it in Lizaveta, the younger 35-year-old stepsister of the woman he plans to murder, Aliona. Aliona is a “shrunken little hag” who “beats her sister, holding her virtually in thrall, as though she were a small child” (p. 71). Despite this mistreatment, Lizaveta still “worked for her sister day and night and served in place of a cook and laundress. In addition, she mended and hired herself out to wash floors. Everything she earned she gave to her sister” even though Aliona’s will was written to give everything to a monastery. Lizaveta gave without receiving anything but violence and hate in return.

One gets a better understanding of her symbolic identity when we hear a description of her from a student. “She was unmarried, terribly uncouth, remarkably tall, with a big splay feet always in battered goatskin shoes, and she kept herself very clean. She was always pregnant.” (p. 72). This last description of Lizaveta is particularly an odd one, since she was not depicted as having children. In light of that description, a soldier to whom the student is talking asks, “She’s a freak?” The student responds, “Well, she’s a bit dark, and she looks like a soldier in disguise. But, you know, she isn’t really a freak. Her face and eyes are rather kind. Yes, very much so. Proof is, there are lots who like her. She is very quiet, very meek…” (p. 72). A clean, dark-skinned, and meek soldier in disguise who is always birthing new life, much like our Savior.

Raskolnikov ends up doing to Lizaveta what we all did to Christ. He murders her while at the same time trying to kill the representation of wickedness in the book, Aliona. This act further magnifies his depraved state of ingratitude and leads to the expressions described above. It culminates with him contemplating jumping off a bridge to kill himself. He ultimately becomes ungrateful for life itself.

Salvation from Ingratitude

Providentially, he does not end his life and, on the way home, ends up encountering Sonia’s drunken father, who had just been run over by a horse-drawn carriage. He takes the dying man to the home with the destitute mother and three children. At that moment, Sonia enters the room, and her father asks forgiveness for his drunkenness, which led to her prostitution. Sonia embraces her father as he dies in her arms.

Upon seeing that moment of forgiveness from one of the book’s three Christ-like figures, Raskolnikov does something odd. He too becomes generous. He gives his only remaining twenty rubles to the new widow, Sonia’s mother. As he leaves, he says to the police officer, “Yes, I am soaked in blood” (p. 190). Literally, the blood is that of the man he carried to the man’s home to die. Symbolically, it is the blood of the God who has died to rescue him. 

As a result, he finds himself having a new sensation, the “sensation of a man condemned to death who is suddenly and unexpectedly pardoned” (p.190). Dostoevsky knew this sensation well. In real life, he too had literally been condemned to death by the Russian Tsar but had been pardoned right as he was about to be shot. That experience changed his whole life as well, helping him understand more deeply the agape love of Christ and God’s pardon of our sins, including our sin of ingratitude. 

After Raskolnikov’s moment of generosity, one of the young, destitute, and now fatherless children, Polechka, runs up to him. Raskolnikov asks her, “Do you love your sister Sonia?” Polechka declares of her sacrificial sister prostituting herself for their well-being, “I love her more than anybody.” Suddenly encountering this declaration of love, Raskolnikov makes his first request for help to a helpless little girl who just lost her father. He realizes that he, too, a murderer, could be loved: “Will you love me?” She responds by reaching up, kissing him, hugging him, and weeping.

He follows with his second request for help, “Pray for me sometimes too” (191). She, despite her destitution and recent loss, replies with a promise, “I’ll pray for you the whole rest of my life.” In that moment, Raskolnikov suddenly ceased to be the self-sufficient individual who needed no help or charity from anyone. He had requested and experienced generous love and accepted his need for it. 

He leaves, asking himself, “‘Wasn’t I alive just now?” Dostoevsky writes of that moment, “He was not the same man he had been a moment before” (p. 192). He had recognized what he was meant to be: a grateful, love-receiving image-bearer of God.

For more on my thoughts on Dostoevsky’s Crime and Punishment, listen to my conversation with Nadya Williams on the Christians Reading Classics podcast.

Footnotes

  1. As I mentioned in an earlier post, Dostoevsky wrote in Notes from Underground that the best definition of a human is “a being that goes on two legs and is ungrateful.” Fyodor Dostoyevsky, Notes from the Underground, trans. Richard Pevear and Larissa Volokhonsky (Vintage, 1993), 29.
  2. All quotes are taken from Fyodor Dostoyevsky, Crime and Punishment, trans. Sydney Monas (Signet, 1968).

Perry L. Glanzer

Baylor University
Perry L. Glanzer, Ph.D., is Professor of Educational Foundations and a Resident Scholar with Baylor Institute for Studies of Religion.

Leave a Reply