Skip to main content

I hear it everywhere. In radio and television commercials, even coming off the lips of talk radio hosts. I hear it in classrooms, in speeches and addresses—from high school graduations to university faculty meetings, and, yes, even from the pulpit. It is the sound of AI.

Over the years, I’ve detected certain features of AI’s preferred style. Of course, AI does not have a copyright on any of these stylistic features (not yet, anyway), and it certainly did not invent them. However, my antennae awaken whenever I hear certain patterns, and I can’t help but think, “This is AI.”  (Admittedly, I think this with dread, disgust, and even shame that I have grown such antennae. But in this time of inhuman technologies, should I be surprised to find that I, Gregor Samsa-like, am growing a bit inhuman myself?)

First, there’s the sharply defined contrast, often formulated thusly: “This is not X, but Y.” Or more often “Not merely X. It is . . . Y.”  For instance, in a discussion of ice cream, AI might spout, “Ice cream is not merely a tasty treat. It ties communities together.”  I first became aware of this favorite AI formula when one of my students turned in a paper in which this phrasing was used at least once, and sometimes twice, in every body paragraph of a lengthy paper. Human beings don’t usually write that way.

And then, the tricolon. (One positive of the AI age is that it has forced me to look up the names of rhetorical techniques I never knew.)  The tricolon is the use of three elements—separated by commas—to embellish a description. For instance, “Everyone loves the cool, smooth, and rich flavor of my aunt’s homemade ice cream.”  Human beings have always loved the tricolon—at least since the time of Caesar’s “I came, I saw, I conquered.” There’s a certain rightness to the rhythm of any sentence that includes a nice set of three adjectives, nouns, or verbs. The problem is that they are devilishly hard to invent. I mean, I spent five minutes just coming up with the three adjectives that described ice cream a few sentences ago. Who among us has that kind of time to spend adding weight and balance to our sentences and paragraphs? I guess that’s one reason AI is so popular.

The em-dash has had its day, and many have commented on AI’s favoring of this device. “I remember the summers of my midwestern childhood—the joy of hearing the ice-cream truck’s pleasant jingle, and my friends and I rushing to be the first in line to purchase an orange push-up popsicle or ice-cream sandwich.”  (Probably AI would not be quite so specific as to mention an orange push-up popsicle. That detail was retrieved from my own precious memory bank!)

And verbosity. Human beings get tired of writing pretty quickly. I’m pushing myself past my normal bedtime as I work through this paragraph. But AI doesn’t get sleepy or bored or embarrassed if it starts sounding a bit redundant. In the past two years I’ve read lengthier memos and sat through longer addresses than I’d ever thought probable. I can’t help but think the reason is AI. A human bureaucrat does not think of every possible issue a committee might need to consider—just the top three, maybe four. AI opens the firehose of contingencies. A normal person thinks of the top three or four personal qualities of a deceased family member for a eulogy. AI pushes the limits of our capacity for fond remembrance of Aunt Sylvia’s many, many virtues.

AI is writing on steroids. It’s a hyped-up style—always catchy, snappy, thorough, and style-conscious. I guess I’ll get used to it. I’ll have to. As our kids grow up reading and listening to AI, they’ll internalize all its habits, and that’s what they’ll think good communication sounds like. They won’t know of a time when most paragraphs ended without tricolons, em-dashes were few and far between, and we only occasionally thought of that snappy, “Not/But” contrast.

By then, who knows? Maybe I’ll have grown another pair of antennae or perhaps a carapace that includes wings on my back, and I’ll be able to fly to some other hive, disgusted with the humanity I no longer resemble.

But before that happens, I’d like to offer a challenge for us as Christian scholars. Whenever we stand in front of a classroom, or a meeting, or a congregation, or whenever we are asked to write—even if it’s an email memorandum—can we promise to be authentic?  Can we promise our listeners or our readers that we will use our own thoughts and our own words?  I know that as a listener and reader of others, that’s what I would most appreciate. How I relish it, these days, whenever I see in a student’s work an awkward phrase, slightly immature diction, or even a grammatical error. At least I know that’s the student’s own mind at work!  How I tire when I hear someone mouthing nothing but the stale machinations of potentially catastrophic software.

Jesus said, “The good man brings good things out of the good stored up in his heart, and the evil man brings evil things out of the evil stored up in his heart. For out of the overflow of the heart, the mouth speaks” (Luke 6:45). Let’s not allow our hearts to be spoken for by the software that wants to take command. Let’s determine among ourselves to speak from the heart.

N. S. Boone

N. S. Boone, English Language & Literature, Harding University.

Leave a Reply